Category Archives: Design

The Power of Surprise

The Power of Surprise

GUEST POST from Mike Shipulski

There’s disagreement on what is creative, innovative and disruptive. And there is no set of hard criteria to sort concepts into the three categories. Stepping back a bit, a lesser but still important sorting is an in-or-out categorization. Though not as good as discerning among the three, it is useful to decide if a new concept is in (one of the three) or out (not).

The closest thing to an acid test is assessment of the emotional response generated by a new concept. Here are some responses that I consider tell-tail signs of powerful ideas/concepts worthy of the descriptors creative, innovative, or disruptive.

When first shown, a prototype creates fear and defensiveness. The fear signals that the prototype threatens the status quo and defensiveness is objective evidence of the fear.

When first explained, a new concept creates anger and aggression. Because the concept doesn’t play by the rules, it disrespects everything holy, and the unfairness spawns indigence.

After some time, the dismissive comments about the new prototype fade and turn to discussions colored by deep sadness as the gravity of the situation hits home.

But the best leading indicator is surprise. When a test result doesn’t match your expectations, it generates surprise. And since your expectations are built on your mental models, surprising concepts contradict your mental models. And since your mental models are formed by successful experiences, prototypes that create surprise violate previous success.

If you’re surprised by a new concept, it’s worth a deeper look. If you’re not surprised, move on.

If you’re not tolerant of surprise, you should be. And if you are tolerant of surprise, it’s time to become fervent.

Image credits: Pexels

Subscribe to Human-Centered Change & Innovation WeeklySign up here to join 17,000+ leaders getting Human-Centered Change & Innovation Weekly delivered to their inbox every week.

Make it Easy

Make it Easy

GUEST POST from Mike Shipulski

When you push, you make it easy for people resist. When you break trail, you make it easy for them to follow.

Efficiency is overrated, especially when it interferes with effectiveness. Make it easy for effectiveness to carry the day.

You can push people off a cliff or build them a bridge to the other side. Hint – the bridge makes it easy.

Even new work is easy when people have their own reasons for doing it.

Making things easier is not easy.

Don’t tell people what to do. Make it easy for them to use their good judgement.

Set the wrong causes and conditions and creativity screeches to a halt. Set the right ones and it flows easily. Creativity is a result.

Don’t demand that people pull harder, make it easier for them to pull in the same direction.

Activity is easy to demonstrate and progress isn’t. Figure out how to make progress easier to demonstrate.

The only way to make things easier is to try to make them easier.

Image credits: Unsplash

Subscribe to Human-Centered Change & Innovation WeeklySign up here to join 17,000+ leaders getting Human-Centered Change & Innovation Weekly delivered to their inbox every week.

The Holy Grail of Additive Manufacturing

The Holy Grail of Additive Manufacturing

GUEST POST from Mike Shipulski

The holy grail of Additive Manufacturing (AM) is high volume manufacturing. And the reason is profit. Here’s the governing equation:

(Price – Cost) x Volume = Profit

The idea is to sell products for more than the cost to make them and sell a lot of them. It’s an intoxicatingly simple proposition. And as long as you look only at the volume – the number of products sold per year – life is good. Just sell more and profits increase. But for a couple reasons, it’s not that simple. First, volume is a result. Customers buy products only when those products deliver goodness at a reasonable price. And second, volume delivers profit only when the cost is less than the price. And there’s the rub with AM.

Here’s a rule – as volume increases, the cost of AM is increasingly higher than traditional manufacturing. This is doubly bad news for AM. Not only is AM more expensive, its profit disadvantage is particularly troubling at high volumes. Here’s another rule – if you’re looking to AM to reduce the cost of a part, look elsewhere. AM is not a bottom-feeder technology.

If you want to create profits with AM, use it to increase price. Use it to develop products that do more and sell for more. The magic of AM is that it can create novel shapes that cannot be made with traditional technologies. And these novel shapes can create products with increased function that demand a higher price. For example, AM can create parts with internal features like serpentine cooling channels with fine-scale turbulators to remove more heat and enable smaller products or products that weigh less. Lighter automobiles get better fuel mileage and customers will pay more. And parts that reduce automobile weight are more valuable. And real estate under the hood is at a premium, and a smaller part creates room for other parts (more function) or frees up design space for new styling, both of which demand a higher price.

Now, back to cost. There’s one exception to cost rule. AM can reduce total product cost if it is used to eliminate high cost parts or consolidate multiple parts into a single AM part. This is difficult to do, but it can be done. But it takes some non-trivial cost analysis to make the case. And, because the technology is relatively new, there’s some aversion to adopting AM. An AM conversion can require a lot of testing and a significant cost reduction to take the risk and make the change.

To win with AM, think more function AND consolidation. More (or new) function to support a higher price (and increase volume) and reduced cost to increase profit per part. Don’t do one or the other. Do both. That’s what GE did with its AM fuel nozzle in their new aircraft engines. They combined 20 parts into a single unit which weighed 25 percent less than a traditional nozzle and was more than five times as durable. And it reduced fuel consumption (more function, higher price).

AM is well-established in prototyping and becoming more established in low-volume manufacturing. The holy grail for AM – high volume manufacturing – will become a broad reality as engineers learn how to design products to take advantage of AM’s unique ability to make previously un-makeable shapes and learn to design for radical part consolidation.

More function AND radical part consolidation. Do both.

Image credits: Unsplash

Subscribe to Human-Centered Change & Innovation WeeklySign up here to join 17,000+ leaders getting Human-Centered Change & Innovation Weekly delivered to their inbox every week.

Cede or Seed: What’s Your Innovation Strategy?

Cede or Seed: What's Your Innovation Strategy?

GUEST POST from Robyn Bolton

To Cede, or to Seed, that is the question:

Whether ‘tis nobler in the mind to suffer

The slings and arrows of a down quarter or year,

Or to take arms against the Tyranny of Now

And by opposing overcome it.

To Cede – to withdraw,

Spend no more; and by stopping to say we end

The innovation and the thousand natural insights

That pave the way: ‘tis a necessity

Stoically to be endured

To Seed, to spend;

To spend perchance to grow – ay there’s the rub:

For in that spending on innovation what revenue may come,

When we have emerged from this uncertainty,

Must give us hope – there’s the advantage

That makes success of such a business

  • Hamlet, if he were a senior executive making budget decisions during periods of uncertainty (and with my deepest apologies to Shakespeare)
The Question

To cede or seed is the question facing so many executives right now.

The same question faced executives in 2001, 2008, and 2020.

And an answer is required.

But what’s the right answer?

As a friend likes to say, “It’s contextual.”

To Cede

Cede is the most common answer for two main reasons: (1) executives feel they don’t have a choice because super-senior executives mandated an x% budget, or (2) executives need to boost results by allocating resources to things with “guaranteed” ROI.

Whatever the reason, innovation is a luxury the business can no longer afford, and the core business is a necessity to be supported at all costs. As a result, rather than scaling back a little in a lot of places, managers believe it is safer and easier to eliminate innovation entirely and maintain, or even increase, resources for operations.

Sometimes, this is also the right answer.

If the business is hemorrhaging cash, its value is plummeting, and people are questioning whether or not it can stay in business, then Cede is the right answer. There’s no sense in investing for success in one, three, or five years if there’s little chance of seeing the next day, week, or month.

But odds are, you’re not in that situation.

To Seed

The Dot-com bubble. The Great Recession. COVID-19 recession.

The 21st century has allowed us to study the impact of different decisions during and after economic crises.

And when it comes to innovation, evidence shows that companies that continue to invest in innovation during times of economic uncertainty outperformed the market by 10% during the crisis and by up to 30% in the five years immediately following the crisis.

But not all companies.

A study of 4,700 companies during three global recessions (1980 – 1982, 1990 – 1991, and 2000 – 2002) found that “Businesses that boldly invest more than their rivals during a recession… enjoy only a 26% chance of becoming leaders after a downturn.”  However,

“Companies that master the delicate balance between cutting costs to survive today and investing to grow tomorrow do well after a recession. Within this group, a subset that deploys a specific combination of defensive and offensive moves has the highest probability—37%—of breaking away from the pack. These companies reduce costs selectively by focusing more on operational efficiency than their rivals do, even as they invest relatively comprehensively in the future by spending on marketing, R&D, and new assets. Their multipronged strategy…is the best antidote to a recession.”

The takeaway – Seed, don’t splurge.

The Answer (sort of)

It’s easy, and incredibly biased, of me to assert that there is one and only one right answer. That the executive who cuts innovation spending (along with travel budgets and probably a few other things) is woefully short-sighted and dooming his business to a never-ending cycle of cutting back, losing ground, and racing to catch up, only to cut again when the next downturn hits.

It’s also very unfair because I’d be using history and theory to judge an executive grappling with the reality of organizational mandates, limited resources, and very real responsibilities.

The right answer is the one you can live with.

Ceding makes sense in the short term, but it’s a liability in the medium and long term.

Seeding pays off in 2-3 years, but you’ll endure skepticism and risk your bonus or job while waiting.

Research says Seeding is the right answer.

Reality often dictates Ceding.

The choice is yours.

Just remember that, like Hamlet, you live (or die) with the results. Innovation

Image credit: Pixabay

Subscribe to Human-Centered Change & Innovation WeeklySign up here to join 17,000+ leaders getting Human-Centered Change & Innovation Weekly delivered to their inbox every week.

Mixed Reality Headsets Meet the Dead Zone

Mixed Reality Headsets Meet the Dead Zone

GUEST POST from Geoffrey Moore

My colleague and social media maven, Rich Stimbra, forwards me news items that might spark a blog post, like the following a couple of years ago:

Meta has scuttled development of a high-end mixed-reality headset meant to compete with Apple’s Vision Pro starting in 2027, The Information reports, citing anonymous sources. Production cost was a primary factor, since Meta was using the same micro OLED display tech as Apple, but trying to keep the headset under $1,000 in order to attract buyers. Apple’s $3,500 Vision Pro, meanwhile, is “stuck in neutral,” per Business Insider. Falling U.S. sales will be offset somewhat by its international launch in June, but the Vision Pro has no must-have app yet — and a more affordable model is expected next year.

This was clearly a technology adoption problem, and clients often ask members of The Chasm Group how you can tell where a given category is in the Technology Adoption Life Cycle, and how should that impact your commitment to the opportunity?

One tool we use is called the Pain/Gain matrix, as illustrated in the two charts that follow. The first chart tees up a thought experiment exercise. Looking at the disruptive innovation you are seeking to bring to market, ask yourself how much gain does it deliver, and how much pain must the customer go through to get it? In so doing, don’t just consider the end user, also take into account the other constituencies that must support the purchase. This is particularly germane to B2B enterprises, so you have to squint a bit to apply it to consumer markets. That said, here is the framework:

Pain Gain Matrix

The executive sponsor is the one who has to pay for this, the process owner is the one who has to secure the productivity improvement from it, the systems owner is the one who has to install and support it, and the end user is the one who has to actually extract the benefits from it. Each one has their own pain/gain experience, so they need to be placed separately. (In consumer markets, all four roles could condense into one, although in many families they may be distributed across either one or both parents as well younger and older siblings.)

The goal of the thought experiment is for the team to reach a consensus on the most likely square for each of the four stakeholders based on the current offer in the market today. Once you have all four placed in one (and only one) square, then you can turn to the second chart, which serves as a kind of decoder ring in that it predicts where you are likely to be in the adoption life cycle and what you will have to do to be successful at that stage.

Dead Zone Matrix

Following the Technology Adoption Life Cycle around the edges of the diagram

One might expect that the life cycle would proceed from the upper right to the lower left on a diagonal path, a straight line being the shortest distance between two points. It turns out that is not the case.

For the Early Market, a high-pain, high-gain proposition is OK provided the size of the gain is massive. That is, if you can deliver a truly transformative outcome, early adopters are willing to put up with a considerable amount of pain (and expense) to get it. However, if it is anything less than truly transformative, then they won’t play. That is why the winning Early Market operating model is a bespoke project wherein you and they put serious skin in the game, including assigning your best and brightest to the effort and simply refusing to stop until you have got the thing all the way to bright. The key to this stage is to have a visionary executive sponsor who will commit not only to fund the outcome but to continue to support it through its struggles until it gets all the way to the finish.

For the Bowling Alley (including the critical crossing the chasm step) the critical issue is still very much the size of the gain, what we call the compelling reason to buy, but the ability to absorb pain is much less. Here we have a pragmatist process owner who is under direct pressure to fix a broken mission-critical process that they cannot remediate with conventional solutions. They are desperate for a solution to their problem, what we call the whole product, which will be a huge gain for them. However, they do not have the resources to fund a bespoke project, which means they cannot absorb a great deal of pain. As a result, the vendor has to bring the whole product to them, partners included, and keep everyone committed to stay the course until the fix is up and running and proven successful. The process owner is willing to pitch in here, and so can absorb some pain in order to get to their goal, but nowhere near as much as the Early Market visionary executive.

For a Tornado to form, two things must change. The first is the emergence of a killer app that makes everyone and their mother want the new thing—that’s the big gain that has broad appeal. The second is that there has to be a major reduction in pain—a big drop in the friction that has been holding the category back to date. The goal is to sell a stripped-down, friction-free killer app that has a super-short time to value and then expand over time to address adjacent opportunities that may require more development but which can be readily absorbed because the core product is already installed. During the Tornado proper, particularly at its outset, it is the systems owners who are under the gun to procure and deploy the killer app as fast as possible. Their speed is gaited by whatever friction is still present, so the more this can be removed, the faster the tornado can spin up and the further it can spread. The company that does this best typically takes the field, becomes installed as the category gorilla, and generates outsized returns for many years to come.

Finally, when technology adoption comes to Main Street, we are now in the expand part of the land-and-expand playbook, where the gaiting item is how many different use cases it can support in how many different contexts and whether the offer can be converted from a licensable product to a consumable service. Under such conditions, because the amount of pain to adopt has been reduced to a bare minimum, it takes less and less gain to drive additional market growth. The end users are the ones who most benefit, and success rides increasingly on securing distribution channels that get to them as directly as possible and making it as easy as pie for them to try and buy, or at least try and then get their system owner to buy.

The Dead Zone

As you can see, the Life Cycle follows a path from the upper right to the lower left of the diagram by skirting around the edges. What about all the other squares?

Well, the ones that are blacked out are simply non-starters. The pain exceeds the gain to the point that no one other than a technology enthusiast would want to engage. But the four squares in the very center of the diagram are the ones that are the most dangerous. Collectively they make up the Dead Zone, which is another way of seeing the chasm, or what Intel used to call the Valley of Death.

Products in the Dead Zone deliver good (but not amazing) gains, but they do so at the cost of real (although not excruciating) pain. This combination is the kiss of death. It causes prospective customers to express real interest in the offer (“We’d love to take a meeting and see a demo”), but it does not motivate them sufficiently to get them to actually buy. It is hard to imagine a greater waste of go-to-market resources than that. Start-ups, as well as in-house incubations who venture out into such a desert usually die of thirst, meaning they don’t get that life-supporting next round of funding.

It is kind of like a LaBrea Tar Pit that swallows up whole species, as witnessed by the Sharp’s Personal Digital Assistant, RCA’s 8-track tape, and Mazda’s rotary automobile engine, as well as the . . .

Mixed Reality Headset

This sucker has Dead Zone written all over it. And because it is being positioned as a consumer product, it has a much tougher row to hoe. There is simply no chance of it getting traction unless and until someone can bring to market a killer app at a consumer price point, which will require some very deep pockets to get there, not to mention incredible design skills to get it right.

A much slower but more achievable path would target a B2B customer base with Bowling Alley applications that address urgent problems with mission-critical business processes. An obvious example relates to the “aging out of the workforce” problems that industrial manufacturers are facing, both in the factory and in field services. There simply are not enough trained technicians to meet the need, especially now that many of these industries are moving back onshore. Mixed reality headsets can be used to enable just-in-time training for onboarding inexperienced workers better, faster, cheaper, and even more importantly, safer than conventional alternatives.

Is this a killer app? Heck no, but it is a start; it can support a higher price point, and it can create enough volume to warrant investing in lower-cost approaches. What it cannot do is be rushed. The biggest cause of Dead Zone casualties is a management team that thinks a tornado is upon them when in fact it is just a Hype Cycle hitting its peak.

That’s what I think. What do you think?

— Image credit: Pexels, Geoffrey Moore

Subscribe to Human-Centered Change & Innovation WeeklySign up here to join 17,000+ leaders getting Human-Centered Change & Innovation Weekly delivered to their inbox every week.

What is Experience Design?

What is Experience Design?

by Braden Kelley and Art Inteligencia


What Is Experience Design? (Short Answer)

Experience design is the human-centered discipline of researching, mapping, measuring, and improving the end-to-end interactions people have with an organization — customers, employees, partners, and other stakeholders. It includes screens, and it also includes waiting, handoffs, policy, human help, and the backstage work that makes the frontstage possible. A finished interface is not a finished experience.

Experience design is finished when a person can succeed across the whole journey — not when a screen looks finished.

Below you’ll find what the work includes, what it is often confused with, who it is for, and how you know you are practicing it. This definition aligns with the one in my Experience Design Glossary.

What Does Experience Design Actually Include?

Experience design is a practice, not a deliverable. The work has a sequence, and skipping a step is how organizations ship polished surfaces on broken journeys.

  1. Research the lived job. Start from what people are trying to do, in their context, with their constraints — not from an internal process diagram. Evidence beats the intended journey.
  2. Map the whole path, including the seams. Stages, channels, emotions, waits, handoffs, and recovery. A map that only shows the happy path is a poster. The frictions people feel before the map does are catalogued in 12 Friction Points Customers Feel Before Your Journey Map Does.
  3. Design frontstage and backstage together. What people see — interfaces, spaces, messages, human encounters — only works if tools, policy, incentives, and partner handoffs can support it.
  4. Measure whether the job got done. Effort, completion, recontact, recovery quality, and return behavior. A relationship score can be one signal. It is not the design brief.
  5. Improve what the evidence shows, including the operating model: who owns the seam, who has authority to make it right, and which old path still runs the place.

You can learn a great deal of that before you build. Concierge tests, service rehearsals, and recovery walkthroughs falsify a journey while it is still cheap to change — the methods in 10 Ways to Prototype Experience Without Building a Product.

If the backstage cannot keep the promise, the frontstage is theater.

What Is Experience Design Not?

  • Not interface design or UX by itself. Interface design shapes controls, layouts, and interaction on a surface. Experience design asks whether a person can finish the job with dignity before, during, and after that surface. The side-by-side is in 7 Differences Between Interface Design and Experience Design.
  • Not a journey map as the finished product. Maps align a team. They do not prove the lived experience matches the drawing. Design continues into ownership, measurement, and change.
  • Not a replacement word for service design. Service design aligns frontstage experiences with backstage people, processes, and partners so a service delivers reliably. Experience design is the broader discipline: it uses service design when the object is a service, and it also covers products, workplaces, partner relationships, and other stakeholder journeys. When service design optimizes internal speed while people absorb the cost, you get efficient misery — the pattern in 8 Service Design Mistakes That Create Efficient Misery.
  • Not a dashboard program. Listening without redesign is scorekeeping. Experience design changes the journey.

Hiring for screens, posting a map, and tracking a score can all be useful. None of them is the whole discipline.

Who Is Experience Design For?

Every relationship with an organization is an experience system. The same discipline applies; the audience changes.

  • Customers — whether the job gets done with dignity before, during, and after purchase. See What Is Customer Experience?
  • Employees — whether people can finish real work across hiring, tools, leadership, and change, because poor employee experience usually becomes poor customer experience. See What Is Employee Experience — and Why Does It Shape CX?
  • Partners — whether distributors, suppliers, agencies, and other ecosystem partners can onboard, deliver, get support, and get paid. From the customer’s point of view, partners are often an extension of the brand. See What Is Partner Experience — and Why Does It Matter?
  • Other stakeholders — patients, constituents, members, and communities, whenever a person has to succeed across time, channels, and institutional rules.

Designing one audience while ignoring the people and partners who deliver the journey pushes the failure into a seam nobody owns.

Experience design is stakeholder-specific in the research and shared in the system. One broken backstage shows up in more than one audience.

How Do You Know You Are Doing Experience Design?

  1. Can you name the job a specific person is trying to finish, in their words, not only your process step?
  2. Are frontstage and backstage in the same design, including policy, incentives, tools, and partner handoffs?
  3. Does someone own the seams, not only the channels that look good alone?
  4. Have you tested the lived path — including failure and recovery — before treating the build as the proof?
  5. Did behavior change: less unpaid effort, fewer retellings, recovery that has power, people who come back because the job worked?

If the interface is green and the job still fails, you designed a surface. Experience design starts where that surface ends.

FAQ: What Is Experience Design?

What is experience design in simple words?

Experience design is the work of researching, mapping, measuring, and improving how people interact with an organization from start to finish. It covers screens, people, waiting, handoffs, policy, and the behind-the-scenes work that makes those moments possible. The test is whether a person can succeed, not whether a single touchpoint looks polished.

What is the difference between experience design and UX?

UX usually focuses on how people use a product or interface. Experience design covers the end-to-end journey across channels, time, human help, policy, and operations. A strong interface can still sit inside a weak experience if seams, waiting, or recovery fail.

What is the difference between experience design and service design?

Service design aligns what people see with the people, processes, and systems behind a service so value is delivered reliably. Experience design is the broader discipline of shaping interactions for customers, employees, partners, and other stakeholders. Service design is a core method inside experience design when what you are designing is a service.

What does an experience designer do?

An experience designer studies the real job people are trying to do, maps journeys including handoffs and failure, designs both the visible moments and the operating model behind them, tests the experience before a full build, and measures whether people succeed with less effort. The role is cross-functional. It is not limited to screens.

How do you know experience design is working?

People finish the job without heroics, retelling, or workarounds. Seams have owners. Recovery has real authority. Effort and recontact fall. A prettier interface or a higher survey score, on its own, does not prove the experience was designed.

Image credits: Pexels

Content Authenticity Statement: The topic area, key elements to focus on, etc. were decisions made by Braden Kelley, with a little help from Cursor to clean up the article, add images and create infographics.

Subscribe to Human-Centered Change & Innovation WeeklySign up here to get Human-Centered Change & Innovation Weekly delivered to your inbox every week.

Evolving New Ideas

Evolving New Ideas

GUEST POST from Mike Shipulski

Before there is something new to see, there is just a good idea worthy of a prototype. And before there can be good ideas there are a whole flock of bad ones. And until you have enough self confidence to have bad ideas, there is only the status quo. Creating something from nothing is difficult.

New things are new because they are different than the status quo. And if the status quo is one thing, it’s ruthless in desire to squelch the competition. In that way, new ideas will get trampled simply based on their newness. But also in that way, if your idea gets trampled it’s because the status quo noticed it and was threatened by it. Don’t look at the trampling as a bad sign, look at it as a sign you are on the right track. With new ideas there’s no such thing as bad publicity.

The eureka moment is a lie. New ideas reveal themselves slowly, even to the person with the idea. They start as an old problem or, better yet, as a successful yet tired solution. The new idea takes its first form when frustration overcomes intellectual inertia a strange sketch emerges on the whiteboard. It’s not yet a good idea, rather it’s something that doesn’t make sense or doesn’t quite fit.

The idea can mull around as a precursor for quite a while. Sometimes the idea makes an evolutionary jump in a direction that’s not quite right only to slither back to it’s unfertilized state. But as the environment changes around it, the idea jumps on the back of the new context with the hope of evolving itself into something intriguing. Sometimes it jumps the divide and sometimes it slithers back to a lower energy state. All this happens without conscious knowledge of the inventor.

It’s only after several mutations does the idea find enough strength to make its way into a prototype. And now as a prototype, repeats the whole process of seeking out evolutionary paths with the hope of evolving into a product or service that provides customer value. And again, it climbs and scratches up the evolutionary ladder to its most viable embodiment.

Creating something new from scratch is difficult. But, you are not alone. New ideas have a life force of their own and they want to come into being. Believe in yourself and believe in your ideas. Not every idea will be successful, but the only way to guarantee failure is to block yourself from nurturing ideas that threaten the status quo.

Take the Next Step: Design Out Product Cost

Ready to maximize profit margins and streamline your manufacturing processes? Join us for the interactive webinar, Designing Out Product Cost, and discover battle-tested methods that have boosted profit per square foot by 7X and slashed warranty costs by 4X. You’ll gain access to real-world before-and-after case studies, data-driven design approaches, and practical implementation strategies you can apply right away.

📅 Date & Time: October 29, 2026, at 11:00 AM EST

💵 Investment: $100.00

🎁 Early Bird Bonus: The first 15 registrants receive a complimentary 30-minute 1-on-1 strategy session!

Image credits: 1 of 1,550+ FREE quotes for your presentations at http://misterinnovation.com

Subscribe to Human-Centered Change & Innovation WeeklySign up here to join 17,000+ leaders getting Human-Centered Change & Innovation Weekly delivered to their inbox every week.

Trust the Test, Not Your Gut

Trust the Test, Not Your Gut

GUEST POST from Mike Shipulski

At first glance, it seems easy to run a good test, but nothing can be further from the truth.

The first step is to define the idea/concept you want to validate or invalidate. The best way is to complete one of these two sentences: I want to learn that [type your idea here] is true. Or, I want to learn that [enter your idea here] is false.

Next, ask yourself this question: What information do I need to validate (or invalidate) [type your idea here]? Write down the information you need. In the engineering domain, this is straightforward: I need the temperature of this, the pressure of that, the force generated on part xyz or the time (in seconds) before the system catches fire. But for people-related ideas, things aren’t so straightforward. Some things you may want to know are: how much will you pay for this new thing, how many will you buy, on a scale of 1 to 5 how much do you like it?

Now the tough part – how will you judge pass or fail? What is the maximum acceptable temperature? What is the minimum pressure? What is the maximum force that can be tolerated? How many seconds must the system survive before catching fire? And for people: What is the minimum price that can support a viable business? How many must they buy before the company can prosper? And if they like it at level 3, it’s a go. And here’s the most importance sentence of the entire post:

The decision criteria must be defined BEFORE running the test.

If you wait to define the go/no-go criteria until after you run the test and review the data, you’ll adjust the decision criteria so you make the decision you wanted to make before running the test. If you’re not going to define the decision criteria before running the test, don’t bother running the test and follow your gut. Your decision will be a bad one, but at least you’ll save the time and money associated with the test.

And before running the test, define the test protocol. Think recipe in a cookbook: a pinch of this, a quart of that, mix it together and bake at 350 degrees Fahrenheit for 40 minutes. The best protocols are simple and clear and result in the same sequence of events regardless of who runs the test. And make sure the measurement method is part of the protocol – use this thermocouple, use that pressure gauge, use the script to ask the questions about price and the number they’d buy.

And even with all this rigor, good judgement is still part of the equation. But the judgment is limited to questions like: did we follow the protocol? Did the measurement system function properly? Do the initial assumptions still hold? Did anything change since we defined the learning objective and defined the test protocol?

To create formal learning objectives, to write well-defined test protocols and to formalize the decision criteria before running the test require rigor, discipline, time and money. But, because the cost of making a bad decision is so high, the cost of running good tests is a bargain at twice the price.

Image credits: NASA Goddard Flight Center

Subscribe to Human-Centered Change & Innovation WeeklySign up here to join 17,000+ leaders getting Human-Centered Change & Innovation Weekly delivered to their inbox every week.

Do You Have Too Many Balls in the Air?

Do You Have Too Many Balls in the Air?

GUEST POST from Mike Shipulski

In today’s world of continuous improvement, everything is seen as an opportunity for improvement. The good news is things are improving. But the bad news is without governance and good judgement, things can flip from “lots of opportunity for improvement” to “nothing is good enough.” And when that happens people would rather hang their heads than stick out their necks.

When there’s an improvement goal is propose like this “We’ve got to improve the throughput of process A by 12% over the next three months.” a company that respects their people should want (and expect) responses like these:

As you know, the team is already working to improve processes C, D, and E and we’re behind on those improvement projects. Is improvement of process A more important than the other three? If so, which project do you want to stop so we can start work on process A? If not, can we wait until we finish one of the existing projects before we start a new one? If not, why are you overloading us when we’re making it clear we already have too much work?

Are we missing customer ship dates on process A? If so, shouldn’t we move resources to process A right now to work off the backlog? If we have no extra resources, let’s authorize some overtime so we can catch up. If not, why is it okay to tolerate late shipments to our customers? Are you saying you want us to do more improvement work AND increase production without overtime?

That’s a pretty specific improvement goal. What are the top three root causes for reduced throughput? Well, if the first part of the improvement is to define the root causes, how do you know we can achieve 12% improvement in 3 months? We learned in our training that Deming said all targets are artificial. Are you trying to impose an artificial improvement target and set us up for failure?

Continuous improvement is infinitely good, but resources are finite. Like it or not, continuous improvement work WILL be bound by the resources on hand. Might as well ask for continuous improvement work in a way that’s in line with the reality of the team’s capacity.

And one thing to remember for all projects – there’s no partial credit. When you’re 80% done on ten projects, zero projects are done. It’s infinitely better to be 100% done on a single project.

Image credits: Pixabay

Subscribe to Human-Centered Change & Innovation WeeklySign up here to join 17,000+ leaders getting Human-Centered Change & Innovation Weekly delivered to their inbox every week.

What is Your Problem?

What is Your Problem?

GUEST POST from Mike Shipulski

If you don’t have a problem, you’ve got a big problem.

It’s important to know where a problem happens, but also when it happens.

Solutions are 90% defining and the other half is solving.

To solve a problem, you’ve got to understand things as they are.

Before you start solving a new problem, solve the one you have now.

It’s good to solve your problems, but it’s better to solve you customers’ problems.

Opportunities are problems in sheep’s clothing.

There’s nothing worse than solving the wrong problem – all the cost with none of the solution.

When you’re stumped by a problem, make it worse then do the opposite.

With problem definition, error on the side of clarity.

All problems are business problems, unless you care about society’s problems.

Odds are, your problem has been solved by someone else. Your real problem is to find them.

Define your problem as narrowly as possible, but no narrower.

Problems are not a sign of weakness.

Before adding something to solve the problem, try removing something.

If your problem involves more than two things, you have more than one problem.

The problem you think you have is never the problem you actually have.

Problems can be solved before, during or after they happen and the solutions are different.

Start with the biggest problem, otherwise you’re only getting ready to solve the biggest problem.

If you can’t draw a closeup sketch of the problem, you don’t understand it well enough.

If you have an itchy backside and you scratch you head, you still have an itch. And it’s the same with problems.

If innovation is all about problem solving and problem solving is all about problem definition, well, there you have it.

Image credits: Pixabay

Subscribe to Human-Centered Change & Innovation WeeklySign up here to join 17,000+ leaders getting Human-Centered Change & Innovation Weekly delivered to their inbox every week.