Tag Archives: Philosophy

Defining Good and Evil

Defining Good and Evil

GUEST POST from Geoffrey Moore

This is entry number three in our ongoing reply to Twenty Philosophical Questions That Are Hard to Wrap Your Head Around. Here is the blurb that introduces it:

The intricacies of ethical standards vary across cultures and contexts add complexity to this ever-debated subject. This debate has been published on the Medium website: The Philosophical Debate on the Nature of Good and Evil: Exploring the Boundaries of Morality offering various definitions and viewpoints, on what qualifies as good or evil conduct as well as the reasons and repercussions behind such behavior. The terms “good” and “evil” are often employed to discuss ethical actions. “Good” generally denotes behaviors that are considered upright such, as aiding others in speaking the truth, and avoiding harm. On the other hand, “evil” pertains to actions that are seen as incorrect like lying, cheating, or causing harm.

The blurb suggests that the key question at stake is what we define good and evil to mean, but I don’t think that is where the challenge lies. Sure, there are grey areas that will give us pause, but the more interesting question to me is how we define good and evil. Here’s what I mean.

In religious traditions, the way we define good and evil is relative to a divine being, either personalized as God or impersonally presented as Being or the Absolute. Either way, it is the governing force for all life, and all living things need to align with it. In this context, moral values are grounded in an objective and transcendent reality independent of humanity. Our job is to engage with this reality as best we can, to experience its impact on our consciousness, and to shape our actions in ways that accord with its principles.

There is a lot to like in this tradition, not least of which is that it frees us from the soup of cultural entanglements involved with taking a more humanist relativist approach. Historically, however, religious institutions, authorized to represent divine guidance, have repeatedly succumbed to corrupt appropriations of power and have used both doctrine and sacred texts to justify horrific actions, often at genocidal levels, in the name of religious war. In Western cultural history, such wars were what gave rise to the Enlightenment and its insistence on separating church and state.

One could wish we would have learned much from this movement, but contemporary theocracies, as well as demagogic politicians, show no signs of so doing, positioning themselves instead to be vehicles for patriarchal suppression, ethnic persecution, and terrorist acts. Tolerance, far from being seen as a virtue, is faulted for failing to express appropriate outrage. Spirituality is displaced by zealotry, benevolence by righteousness, and the opportunity to promote acts of evil skyrockets, something we are constantly forced to bear witness to around the world today.

What are we to do? We cannot abandon ethics, for they are foundational to social stability, and we need standards of good and evil to guide ethical engagement. If these standards are not to come from above, then where are they going to come from?

In The Infinite Staircase I argue they come not from above but from below. The staircase as a whole traces the emergence of reality in layers, beginning with the materialist layers of physics, chemistry, and biology, transitioning to the evolutionary layers of desire, consciousness, values, and culture, culminating in the human-specific layers of language, narrative, analytics, and theory. In this hierarchy of systems, good and evil emerge at the layer of values and get institutionalized via the layer of culture. That is, they get defined prior to the emergence of humanity—how is that even possible?!

The answer is that good and evil, as we understand them, are embedded in the mammalian strategy of living. That is, all mammals share two common values. First, they are compelled to nurture their young, regardless of how much sacrifice that might entail. From this comes the definitions of goodness that are centered on love, with evil being defined as violations of same. Second, all mammals self-organize into communities of governance led by socially powered alpha figures, charged with maintaining both internal and external order and security. From this comes the definitions of goodness that are centered on virtue, with evil again being defined as violations of same.

Of course, as humans, we modify our mammalian roots through the higher-level mechanisms of language, narrative, analytics, and theory. In so doing we create separate and conflicting traditions that can indeed make war upon each other. But goodness and evil per se are universal. We are all mammals first, and everything that separates us from one another emerges thereafter.

We may bemoan this separation, but we should honor the fact that community, which is also inherent in our mammalian nature, by definition entails a boundary between them and us. There is no community without that boundary. Culture is an artifact of community, and it evolves separately in each of its instantiations. Language, narrative, and analytics allow culture and community to transcend time and space, but at the end of the day there will always be a boundary that separates an us from a them. How we reach across that boundary to interact with others outside our community is open to us to choose, but dissolving the boundary is not an option.

The key takeaway from this line of thinking is that our values are universal because they are founded in our mammalian roots. Our ethics, on the other hand, are not universal because they are grounded in culture, which is specific to every community. Good and evil belong to the domain of values. Right and wrong belong to the domain of ethics. The former calls for us to be courageous, the latter to be humble. Many of us struggle most of our lives to get this right.

That’s what I think. What do you think?

— Image credit: 1 of 1,650+ FREE quotes from http://misterinnovation.com

Subscribe to Human-Centered Change & Innovation WeeklySign up here to join 17,000+ leaders getting Human-Centered Change & Innovation Weekly delivered to their inbox every week.

What’s the Truth?

What's the Truth?

GUEST POST from Geoffrey Moore

This is the second in a series of responses to the MSN post “20 Philosophical Questions That Are Hard to Wrap Your Head Around.” We are on Question #2: Is there a truth? Here’s the MSN blurb:

This inquiry challenges the concept of truths, versus realities prompting introspection on the nature of knowledge and certainty. Many philosophers consider truth to be a concept that cannot be fully explained in terms other than truth itself. The accepted perspective is that truth relates to how well our language or thoughts align, with a world that exists independently of our minds. This theory is known as the correspondence theory of truth.

There is a fundamental premise stated here that needs correction, namely that “truth relates to how well our language or thoughts align with a world that exists independently of our minds.” The correspondence theory is indeed one understanding of what constitutes truth, but there are two others that are equally well-accepted perspectives—the coherence theory and the pragmatic theory. Thus, while correspondence is indeed a measure of how well our language and thoughts align with a world that exists independently of our minds, coherence, by contrast, is a measure of how well any given claim aligns with all the other claims we take to be true, basically our body of understanding of how the world works. Pragmatism provides a third perspective on truth, taking it to be a measure of how well any claim we make aligns with the results we get from acting out that claim in the world.

All three of these perspectives are useful, and the good news is they are not mutually exclusive. The way we normally test for truth is first through coherence theory. That is, when we hear a claim, we check to see if it aligns with our existing understanding of things. If it does, we are likely to just accept it and move on. If it does not, however, then we are moved to investigate whether it corresponds to what is actually the case, doing so by examining evidence for or against the claim. If the evidence does indeed warrant the claim, then we are moved to modify our body of beliefs to absorb this new bit of understanding into a revised coherence model, what we normally call learning or gaining in experience.

Pragmatism overlays another layer of interest, namely, does this claim enable us to have more success in whatever efforts we have underway? Successful outcomes, in other words, are a form of evidence for the validity of the claim. We have to be careful here, however, for the outcome’s success may be due to some factor other than the one claimed. Nonetheless, when things do work, and especially when this applies to things that traditionally have not worked anywhere near as well in the past, it sends us a strong signal to update our coherence and correspondence models accordingly.

Another challenge that pragmatism poses to our understanding of truth is that lying can also deliver successful outcomes. Lying may often defeat itself in the long run, but in the short run, it can be very effective. How we address lying, however, is normally more of a social issue than a philosophical one. For it to be philosophical, one would need to make the case that lying is foundational to wellbeing, and while such an argument is not unimaginable, it carries with it enough problems that we can safely ignore it for the time being.

What we cannot ignore, on the other hand, is the political use of lying. This is foundational to all authoritarian regimes. In order to stay in power, they must continually maintain a heightened sense of fear and anxiety in the population they govern, at a level sufficient to gain its acquiescence to their corrupt and self-serving ways. How citizens can respond to this challenge is something we will address in a moment.

The core question people want answered about truth, though, is whether or not it is a thing. That is, is truth a force in the world, the way love is or the way beauty is? Historically, the answer to this question was yes because truth, like love and beauty, is taken to be an attribute of the divine being that governs all human experience. In a secular world, however, that answer needs to be revisited. When we do so, we see that the desire for love, beauty, and truth still abides. They do indeed exert a force on us. So, if they are forces in the world, where are they to be found?

My answer is that each one is anchored on a different stair in the Infinite Staircase. Love is grounded on the stairstep of values, an inherent part of our mammalian heritage of nurturing the young. Beauty is grounded on the stairstep of culture, a learned appreciation for esthetic experience. Truth, in this context, is located on the stairstep of narrative, subject to verification delivered from the stairstep of analytics.

Narrative, in other words, is the force in the world that mobilizes the power of truth. True narratives are foundational to both personal and social wellbeing. False narratives undermine these same foundations. Let’s look at examples of both.

The power of true narratives manifests when people act in service to their narrative, even at a cost to their personal self-interests. We call this form of truth integrity, and it is genuinely inspiring because it cements the meaningfulness of their commitments. Existentialism represents an entire philosophy based on this core idea. Its life goal is to be authentic, with authenticity defined as behavior aligned with and in service to whatever life narrative you have chosen for yourself. Truth, in this sense, really does make you free, whereas falsehood imprisons you in narrative contradictions that ultimately destroy your wellbeing, a state that is termed bad faith.

False narratives pose a different problem. The power of truth to combat them depends upon the principled deployment of analytics. Unfortunately, the hold of any narrative on the personality, whether true or false, is frequently stronger than analytics can dislodge. As a result, regardless of how strong the evidence is for falsehood, it is simply denied, allowing bad faith and lack of wellbeing to spread pervasively and sustain their position of power far longer than one might imagine. This is the condition of life under an authoritarian regime.

To dislodge such a regime requires going below the stairstep of competing narratives down to the stairstep of core mammalian values and resurrecting those values that the regime is violating. This is dangerous work, for the regime is well aware of its vulnerability to this tactic and will aggressively punish any signs of it. The prospects for success in the short term are not good, and support from entities outside the regime are likely be necessary to dislodge it, so we should not be surprised to see societies continue to persist under painfully oppressive circumstances.

That said, when the global cannot be addressed, we must retreat and draw in the boundaries to find a local that can be. At the extreme, this would be oneself, although as social creatures, we need the help of a community of others to stay the course, family being our most obvious opportunity. Whatever its nature, that community becomes our reason for being, and it is here that we must use truth to establish the relationships of trust that hold us together. Truth in this context looks more like the medieval troth, a term for fidelity and faithfulness, a kind of integrity that is anchored in our pledge to others to be there for them and with them. Keeping faith is a form of integrity that is well suited to coping with adverse circumstances.

So, is there a truth? Well, in this last sense, there certainly is, as people have proved the world over. As we expand outward from our local scenes, and as we raise the level of abstraction, there will be truth as long as, to borrow a phrase from Yeats, “the center holds.” At some point, it will not, and we must reconcile ourselves to the limits of our mortal perspective, embracing humility and foregoing the kind of righteousness that seeks to impose an answer by force.

That’s what I think. What do you think?

— Image credit: Unsplash

Subscribe to Human-Centered Change & Innovation WeeklySign up here to join 17,000+ leaders getting Human-Centered Change & Innovation Weekly delivered to their inbox every week.

20 Philosophical Questions to Wrap Your Head Around

20 Philosophical Questions to Wrap Your Head Around

GUEST POST from Geoffrey Moore

MSN published a piece with this title, and I am complete sucker for such things, mainly as a way to pressure test the views I express in The Infinite Staircase. I plan to answer as many of these questions as I can, one at a time, and invite you to follow along to play the same game in parallel with your own ideas about what’s what.

Today’s Topic? What is the true essence of reality? You gotta love a question that has three words in it, true, essence, and reality, none of which are readily definable! Here’s the paragraph that follows:

The article titled ‘What Is the True Nature of Reality?‘, published on the Curious Matrix website, explains how throughout history countless philosophers and scientists have grappled with the mysteries of reality. Their exploration encompasses both the realm encompassing matter and particles as well as the intangible aspects of existence. This philosophical dualism has sparked an array of probing questions; What truly constitutes the essence of the mind? How does it relate to the body? Do they exist independently? When we ponder the nature of the reality we inevitably question our perceptions. Contemplate the very core of existence.

By the way, it is worth clicking through to read that article because it goes way beyond the mind/matter dualism that is summarized above. Setting that aside, however, how should we reply to the question itself? Note that it has changed the phrasing from “true nature of reality” to “true essence of reality” which actually makes a difference, and I am going to stick with the former because the latter makes the assumption that reality coalesces into an essence, which is not something I can agree to.

My answer is that the true nature of reality is a hierarchy of systems, each one of which emerges from the ones prior, with no top or bottom system clearly in view. In The Infinite Staircase I make the case for a stack of eleven such systems, beginning with three at the bottom that are materialistic in nature (physics, chemistry, and biology), all of which are all governed by the Second Law of Thermodynamics, or what I call the metaphysics of entropy. These are followed by four systems that are organic in nature (desire, consciousness, values, and culture), representing the evolution of life prior to the arrival of mankind, all governed by the dynamics of natural and sexual selection, or what I call the metaphysics of Darwinism. Those underpinnings tee up the topmost set of systems. ones that are distinctively human in nature (language, narrative, analytics, and theory), all governed by symbols and symbolism, or what I call the metaphysics of memes.

The advantage of this framework is that, instead of limiting ourselves to one or two foundations, we can refer to any of eleven possible platforms, alone or in combination with others, to explain any particular aspect of reality. Here’s how one might take advantage of this to answer the questions that are embedded in the latter half of the paragraph quotes above.

What constitutes the essence of mind? Mind is made up of multiple systems in the staircase, but the primary two are narrative and analytics, both leveraging the system of language. That is, most of our conscious experience is taken up with us telling stories to others or to ourselves and processing those stories to extract knowledge or entertainment. In support of this activity, our minds are powered by our brains, hence involving the stairstep of consciousness and all the material systems below it, so no, our minds cannot be independent of our bodies. At the same time, minds are socially developed, bringing in the stairsteps of values, culture, and language.

In sum, the true nature of our minds is that they are a layer cake of systems interoperating with one another in service to us executing our strategies for living. The fact that we have success in these efforts is demonstrated by the real-world outcome of our continued existence. This suggests that we have no pressing need to question our perceptions. The thing to question instead is the notion that there is a “very core” to our existence, a true essence of reality. That concept is way too monistic, given the complexity of the system’s hierarchy and its interdependent operations.

That’s what I think. What do you think?

— Image credit: Gemini

Subscribe to Human-Centered Change & Innovation WeeklySign up here to join 17,000+ leaders getting Human-Centered Change & Innovation Weekly delivered to their inbox every week.

Top 10 Human-Centered Change & Innovation Articles of September 2025

Top 10 Human-Centered Change & Innovation Articles of September 2025Drum roll please…

At the beginning of each month, we will profile the ten articles from the previous month that generated the most traffic to Human-Centered Change & Innovation. Did your favorite make the cut?

But enough delay, here are September’s ten most popular innovation posts:

  1. McKinsey is Wrong That 80% Companies Fail to Generate AI ROI — by Robyn Bolton
  2. Back to Basics for Leaders and Managers — by Robyn Bolton
  3. Growth is Not the Answer — by Mike Shipulski
  4. The Most Challenging Obstacles to Achieving Artificial General Intelligence — by Art Inteligencia
  5. Charlie Kirk and Innovation — by Art Inteligencia
  6. You Just Got Starbucked — by Braden Kelley
  7. Metaphysics Philosophy — by Geoffrey Moore
  8. Invention Through Co-Creation — by Janet Sernack
  9. Sometimes Ancient Wisdom Needs to be Left Behind — by Greg Satell
  10. The Crisis Innovation Trap — by Braden Kelley and Art Inteligencia

BONUS – Here are five more strong articles published in August that continue to resonate with people:

If you’re not familiar with Human-Centered Change & Innovation, we publish 4-7 new articles every week built around innovation and transformation insights from our roster of contributing authors and ad hoc submissions from community members. Get the articles right in your Facebook, Twitter or Linkedin feeds too!

Build a Common Language of Innovation on your team

Have something to contribute?

Human-Centered Change & Innovation is open to contributions from any and all innovation and transformation professionals out there (practitioners, professors, researchers, consultants, authors, etc.) who have valuable human-centered change and innovation insights to share with everyone for the greater good. If you’d like to contribute, please contact me.

P.S. Here are our Top 40 Innovation Bloggers lists from the last four years:

Subscribe to Human-Centered Change & Innovation WeeklySign up here to get Human-Centered Change & Innovation Weekly delivered to your inbox every week.

Metaphysics Philosophy

Metaphysics Philosophy

GUEST POST from Geoffrey A. Moore

Philosophy is arguably the most universal of all subjects. And yet, it is one of the least pursued in the liberal arts curriculum. The reason for this, I will claim, is that the entire field was kidnapped by some misguided academics around a century ago, and since then no one has paid the ransom to free it. That’s not OK, and with that in mind, here is a series of four blogs that taken together constitute an Emancipation Proclamation.

There are four branches of philosophy, and in order of importance they are

  1. metaphysics,
  2. ethics,
  3. epistemology, and
  4. logic.

This post will address the first of these four, with subsequent posts addressing the remaining three.

Metaphysics is best understood in terms of Merriam-Webster’s definition: “the philosophical study of the ultimate causes and underlying nature of things.” In everyday language, it answers the most fundamental kinds of philosophical questions:

  • What’s happening?
  • What is going on?
  • Where and how do we fit in?
  • In other words, what kind of a hand have we been dealt?

Metaphysics, however, is not normally conceived in everyday terms. Here is what the Oxford English Dictionary (OED) has to say about it in its lead definition:

That branch of speculative inquiry which treats of the first principles of things, including such concepts as being, substance, essence, time, space, cause, identity, etc.; theoretical philosophy as the ultimate science of Being and Knowing.

The problem is that concepts like substance and essence are not only intimidatingly abstract, they have no meaning in modern cosmology. That is, they are artifacts of an earlier era when things like the atomic nature of matter and the electromagnetic nature of form were simply not understood. Today, they are just verbiage.

But wait, things get worse. Here is the OED in its third sense of the word:

[Used by some followers of positivist, linguistic, or logical philosophy] Concepts of an abstract or speculative nature which are not verifiable by logical or linguistic methods.

The Oxford Companion to the Mind sheds further light on this:

The pejorative sense of ‘obscure’ and ‘over-speculative’ is recent, especially following attempts by A.J. Ayer and others to show that metaphysics is strictly nonsense.

Now, it’s not hard to understand what Ayer and others were trying to get at, but do we really want to say that the philosophical study of the ultimate causes and underlying nature of things is strictly nonsense? Instead, let’s just say that there is a bunch of unsubstantiated nonsense that calls itself metaphysics but that isn’t really metaphysics at all. We can park that stuff with magic crystals and angels on the head of a pin and get back to what real metaphysics needs to address—what exactly is the universe, what is life, what is consciousness, and how do they all work together?

The best platform for so doing, in my view, is the work done in recent decades on complexity and emergence, and that is what organizes the first two-thirds of The Infinite Staircase. Metaphysics, it turns out, needs to be understood in terms of strata, and then within those strata, levels or stair steps. The three strata that make the most sense of things are as follows:

  1. Material reality as described by the sciences of physics, chemistry, and biology, or what I called the metaphysics of entropy. This explains all emergence up to the entrance of consciousness.
  2. Psychological and social reality, as explained by the social sciences, or what I called the metaphysics of Darwinism, which builds the transition from a world of mindless matter up to one of matter-less mind, covering the intermediating emergence of desire, consciousness, values, and culture.
  3. Symbolic reality, as explained by the humanities, or what I called the metaphysics of memes, which begins with the introduction of language that in turn enables the emergence of humanity’s two most powerful problem-solving tools, narrative and analytics, culminating in the emergence of theory, ideally a theory of everything, which is, after all, what metaphysics promised to be in the first place.

The key point here is that every step in this metaphysical journey is grounded in verifiable scholarship ranging over multiple centuries and involving every department in a liberal arts faculty—except, ironically, the philosophy department which is holed up somewhere on campus, held hostage by forces to be discussed in later blogs.

That’s what I think. What do you think?

Image Credit: Unsplash

Subscribe to Human-Centered Change & Innovation WeeklySign up here to join 17,000+ leaders getting Human-Centered Change & Innovation Weekly delivered to their inbox every week.

Contemporary Science versus Natural Language

Contemporary Science versus Natural Language

GUEST POST from Geoffrey A. Moore

Item 1. The fastest human-created spacecraft goes 165,000 mph. Pretty amazing. But for it to travel one light year would take roughly 3000 years—basically, the length of recorded human history. The closest star system that hosts an earth-like planet (Alpha Centauri) is 4.4 light years away. Thus, it would take today’s fastest vehicle 14,000 years to make a one-way trip. On our earth, 14,000 years ago humanity’s most sophisticated technology was a stone axe. Thus, while we love to talk about space travel outside the solar system, as well as aliens in UFOs coming to Earth, neither is remotely possible, not now, not ever.

Item 2. There are 30 trillion cells in the average human body. There are 100 trillion atoms in a typical human cell. That means there are three thousand trillion trillion atoms, give or take, in you or me. Atoms are so small that it is not clear any words we have would apply to how they actually operate. Particle and wave are two of the ones we end up using the most. Neither of them, however, can coherently explain something as simple as the double-slit experiment.

Item 3. The metabolic reactions that support all life are mind-bogglingly fast. Take mitochondria for example. They are the organelles that produce the bulk of our ATP, the energy molecule that drives virtually all life’s chemical reactions. Of the 30 trillion cells in your body, on average each one uses around 10 million molecules of ATP per second and can recycle all its ATP in less than a minute. There is simply no way to imagine something happening a million times per second simultaneously in thirty million different places inside your own body.

Item 4. Craig Venter has been quoted as saying, “If you don’t like bacteria, you’re on the wrong planet. This is the planet of the bacteria.” In one-fifth of a teaspoon of seawater, there are a million bacteria (and perhaps 10 million viruses). The human microbiome, which has staked out territory all over our body, in our gut, mouth, skin, and elsewhere, harbors upwards of three thousand kinds of bacteria, comprising some 3 million distinct genes, which they swap with each other wherever they congregate. How in the world are we supposed to keep track of that?

Okay, okay. So what’s your point?

The point is that contemporary science engages with reality across a myriad of orders of magnitude, from the extremely small to the extremely large, somewhere between sixty and one hundred all told. Math can manage this brilliantly. Natural languages cannot. All of which means: philosophers beware!

Philosophers love analogies, and well they should. They make the abstract concrete. They enable us to transport a strategy from a domain where it has been proven effective and test its applicability in a completely different one. Such acts of imagination are the foundation of discovery, the springboard to disruptive innovation. But to work properly they have to be credible. That means they must stand up to the kind of pressure testing that determines the limits to which they can be applied, the boundaries beyond which they must not stretch. This is where the orders of magnitude principle comes in.

It is not credible that there could be a cause that is a million million times smaller than its effect. Yes, it is theoretically conceivable that via a cascading set of emergent relationships, one could build a chain from such an A to such a B, but the amount of coordination that would be required to lever something up a million million times is just ridiculously improbable. So, when philosophers refer to the uncertainty principles embedded in quantum mechanics, and then infer or imply that such uncertainty permeates human affairs, or when they trace consciousness down to quantum fluctuations in messenger RNA, when, in short, they are correlating things that are more than a trillion, trillion times different in size and scope, then they are misusing both the mathematics of science and the resources of natural language. We simply have to stay closer to home.

That’s what I think. What do you think?

Image Credit: 1 of 850+ FREE quote slides available at http://misterinnovation.com

Subscribe to Human-Centered Change & Innovation WeeklySign up here to join 17,000+ leaders getting Human-Centered Change & Innovation Weekly delivered to their inbox every week.

People, Time and Money

People, Time and Money

GUEST POST from Mike Shipulski

If you want the next job, figure out why.
There’s nothing wrong with wanting the job you have.
When you don’t care about the next job it’s because you fit the one you have.

A larger salary is good, but time with family is better.
Less time with family is a downward spiral into sadness.
When you decide you have enough, you don’t need things to be different.

A sense of belonging lasts longer than a big bonus.
A cohesive team is an oasis.
Who you work with makes all the difference.

More stress leads to less sleep and that leads to more stress.
If you’re not sleeping well, something’s wrong.
How much sleep do you get? How do you feel about that?

Leaders lead people.
Helping others grow IS leadership.
Every business is in the people business.

To create trust, treat people like they matter. It’s that simple.
When you do something for someone even though it comes at your own expense, they remember.
You know you’ve earned trust when your authority trumps the org chart.

Image credits: Unsplash

Subscribe to Human-Centered Change & Innovation WeeklySign up here to join 17,000+ leaders getting Human-Centered Change & Innovation Weekly delivered to their inbox every week.

Amazon’s Innovation Philosophy

Amazon's Innovation PhilosophyWhat may have started with a question from @evanjacobs at Amazon.com’s shareholder meeting one year ago, ended with interesting commentary from Amazon’s CEO – Jeff Bezos – on their philosophy around invention, innovation, and risk taking.

The key insights I extracted from Bezos’ response to the question about their lack of big visible market failures and whether Amazon is continuing to take bold enough risks are as follows:

1. Invention versus Innovation

It was very interesting that Jeff Bezos only used the word innovation once in his response, choosing instead to focus on talking about invention. I think that there is an interesting distinction and an important point there. Innovation is not something you do it’s something you’ve done. It’s backward looking to some extent because innovation requires widespread adoption. Innovation definitely can be a goal, while invention can be seen as a component of the pursuit, the attempt to innovate. One important point to remember is that inventions typically cross the bridge from invention to innovation because the solution is not only useful but it is valuable, and the customer makes this determination not you. Another important point – not made by Bezos – is that there are many other factors that go along with invention to create innovation that must be managed, including: psychology, communications, education, trends, politics, legal, and more. This leads me to the second insight extracted from Bezos’ response.

2. “We are willing to be misunderstood for long periods of time”

You may have a great vision for what is possible, but customers may not be ready. There may be incremental improvements or complementary products that must come onto the marketplace before your product can succeed. The political or legal climate may not be right for the transformation your product or service may enable (think Segway). You must seek to understand where you will be misunderstood so you can make plans to address the misunderstandings. If you assume people will ‘just get it once they see it’ you will fail. Also, the more disruptive or radical an innovation the more your communications must shift from explanation to education. But frankly, you can invent amazing things but just be too early. Corning’s Gorilla Glass was invented 50 years ago, and only now is becoming successful. Kindle wasn’t an overnight success, neither was Amazon’s third party seller effort – it took three tries to get it right. Which leads me to the third insight…

3. “We are stubborn on vision. We are flexible on details”

How many leaders can make this distinction accurately between vision and details? How many leaders can throw away their execution to start again in service of their vision? Apple threw away the Motorola ROKR and tried again and came up with the iPhone. Amazon tried three different times to get the third-party sellers just right because they believed in the vision that opening up their store to outside sellers was the right direction to take their business. The key distinction here and the questions to ask yourself when something is failing are the following:

  • “Do we have the wrong vision for where the market is moving or do we have the wrong details?”
  • “Have we misjudged key timing, legal, political, or other aspects in our pursuit of this vision?”

4. “We are planting more seeds right now, and it is too early to talk about them”

This is one of the keys to the pursuit of innovation – not going public too early. Bezos’ captures it perfectly with his comment about it being very difficult to innovate “if you are not willing to be misunderstood”, and I would add that it is very difficult if you are not PREPARED to be misunderstood. You must have a plan. So, innovate early and often, place lots of small bets, continue to invest in the ones that fit your vision and overcome key hurdles, and most importantly keep things quiet until you have a good grasp on exactly how you plan to explain your invention or educate people on its potential value BEFORE you go public – or the road from invention to innovation will only get harder.

What do you think about the Jeff Bezos commentary below?

Continue reading for an excerpt of the text of Bezos’ response, transcribed from the company’s webcast.

“You should anticipate a certain amount of failure. Our two big initiatives, AWS and Kindle — two big, clean-sheet initiatives — have worked out very well. Ninety-plus percent of the innovation at Amazon is incremental and critical and much less risky. We know how to open new product categories. We know how to open new geographies. That doesn’t mean that these things are guaranteed to work, but we have a lot of expertise and a lot of knowledge. We know how to open new fulfillment centers, whether to open one, where to locate it, how big to make it. All of these things based on our operating history are things that we can analyze quantitatively rather than to have to make intuitive judgments.

When you look at something like, go back in time when we started working on Kindle almost seven years ago…. There you just have to place a bet. If you place enough of those bets, and if you place them early enough, none of them are ever betting the company. By the time you are betting the company, it means you haven’t invented for too long.

If you invent frequently and are willing to fail, then you never get to that point where you really need to bet the whole company. AWS also started about six or seven years ago. We are planting more seeds right now, and it is too early to talk about them, but we are going to continue to plant seeds. And I can guarantee you that everything we do will not work. And, I am never concerned about that…. We are stubborn on vision. We are flexible on details…. We don’t give up on things easily. Our third-party seller business is an example of that. It took us three tries to get the third-party seller business to work. We didn’t give up.

But. if you get to a point where you look at it and you say look, we are continuing invest a lot of money in this, and it’s not working and we have a bunch of other good businesses, and this is a hypothetical scenario, and we are going to give up on this. On the day you decide to give up on it, what happens? Your operating margins go up because you stopped investing in something that wasn’t working. Is that really such a bad day?

So, my mind never lets me get in a place where I think we can’t afford to take these bets, because the bad case never seems that bad to me. And, I think to have that point of view, requires a corporate culture that does a few things. I don’t think every company can do that, can take that point of view. A big piece of the story we tell ourselves about who we are, is that we are willing to invent. We are willing to think long-term. We start with the customer and work backwards. And, very importantly, we are willing to be misunderstood for long periods of time.

I believe if you don’t have that set of things in your corporate culture, then you can’t do large-scale invention. You can do incremental invention, which is critically important for any company. But it is very difficult — if you are not willing to be misunderstood. People will misunderstand you.

Any time you do something big, that’s disruptive — Kindle, AWS — there will be critics. And there will be at least two kinds of critics. There will be well-meaning critics who genuinely misunderstand what you are doing or genuinely have a different opinion. And there will be the self-interested critics that have a vested interest in not liking what you are doing and they will have reason to misunderstand. And you have to be willing to ignore both types of critics. You listen to them, because you want to see, always testing, is it possible they are right?

But if you hold back and you say, ‘No, we believe in this vision,’ then you just stay heads down, stay focused and you build out your vision.”

Subscribe to Human-Centered Change & Innovation WeeklySign up here to get Human-Centered Change & Innovation Weekly delivered to your inbox every week.