Tag Archives: HCLTech

Why Putting Employees First and Customers Second Works

Leave a reply

Why Putting Employees First and Customers Second Works

GUEST POST from David Burkus

What if your company announced that, moving forward, it would be place customers second on its list of priorities?

Sounds crazy. The customer is always right. Surely the customer is always first as well.

But that’s exactly what Vineet Nayar, CEO of HCL Technologies did over a decade ago. He announced that the company’s senior leaders would be placing the needs of employees first, and customers second. And the results have been spectacular.

How The Employees First Strategy Started

In 2006, Vineet Nayar, CEO of HCL, a digital engineering company based in India, boldly told his clients they were no longer the company’s top priority. Instead, the focus would be put on employees first. His belief was simple: happy employees make happy customers. Nayar labeled employees who actually interacted with customers as the “value zone,” where the real business magic happens — and any employee in the value zone received the dedicated focus of managers and support functions.

To bring this to life, he flipped the traditional management structure. He made the organizational chart look like an upside-down pyramid. Turning the hierarchy upside down required making managers accountable to front-line employees and ensuring that those in the support functions actually supported those front-line employees, instead of just insisting that they follow the hierarchy’s rigid systems.

Nayar focused his attention on two areas to ensure that the management and support functions served the front-line: reversing accountability and building transparency. Specifically, 360-degree feedback evaluations were expanded to include more front-line workers’ feedback for managers and senior level executives (that’s the accountability), and crucially those evaluations were made public so everyone who contributed to the survey could see the results (there’s your transparency). In addition, when problems occurred for front-line workers, they could create and own support tickets that their managers would have to address (usually, it’s the other way around in top to bottom organizations).

It’s important to note that HCL Technologies wasn’t a little start up in a garage or even a 50-person company. This was done at a 55,000 person, multinational organization. And, spoiler alert, it’s now grown to over 200,000 employees. Pulling off this flip was no small feat, but the results speak for themselves. Employee satisfaction soared, customer service improved, and revenues nearly tripled. By 2009, HCL was named India’s best employer.

Contrast this story with an example of what can go wrong when employee experience is overlooked. In 2001, Robert Nardelli was the newly minted CEO of Home Depot. Expectations were high given his track record at his old job at General Electric, where he had led several successful manufacturing operations.

At Home Depot, Nardelli noticed the stores were staffed with knowledgeable, full-time employees, and in his opinion, a bit too many. What do new leaders, wrongfully, do when they want to make waves and save money?

Yep, he downsized to optimize costs.

He decided to hire more part-timers, many of whom had less expertise in home improvement. The results were not what he expected. Customers quickly noticed the absence of their favorite employees and the decline in service quality. It turned out that managing a service organization like Home Depot was very different from managing a manufacturing operation.

This story underscores a critical point: leading a service organization requires a different approach — one that prioritizes employee engagement and expertise.

“Employees first, customers second” is still about serving the customer, but it’s about serving the customer through the employees whose job it is to serve the customer. Weird how that works, isn’t it? Understand that helping your employees helps your customers. These two parties are intrinsically tied together.

Research On Employees First

Nayar’s success story isn’t an isolated incidence of dumb luck. There’s research behind this. Researchers at Harvard University found a link between employee satisfaction and profitability. They took aim at a long-standing assumption in the business world that market share is the primary driver of profitability. If a company can increase market share, the thinking went, it will increase sales while taking advantage of economies of scale to lower costs and thus increase profits.

However, when they examined a variety of companies and the existing research, they found that market share is one factor in profitability. But that another factor better explains the most profitable companies: customer loyalty.

Based on their research, they estimated that a mere 5 percent increase in customer loyalty can yield a 25 to 85 percent increase in profitability.

Here’s how it works in practice: Profits are driven by customer loyalty. Customer loyalty is driven by employee satisfaction. And employee satisfaction is driven by putting employees first. They called this The Service-Profit Chain and managers who understand this can create a thriving cycle where employee and customer satisfaction drive each other, ultimately leading to greater business success.

In simple terms, if your business provides a service that your employees have front-line participation in, they are in essence an embodiment of the company, not you or the CEO. The entire brand, the experience, the service rests on those front-line employees. If they aren’t taken care of — if they aren’t satisfied — the customer tends to notice.

How Employees First Creates Customer Loyalty

Employee loyalty is a deep indicator of future performance for service organizations. It’s worth noting that there is a subtle difference between employee satisfaction and employee loyalty. Satisfaction derives from how happy employees are in their role. Loyalty comes from having a real stake in the success of the business. Without loyalty, employees leave for better opportunities, then high turnover rates drive up recruitment and training costs, disrupt productivity, and can negatively impact customer experiences. When employees stay longer, companies save on hiring costs, maintain productivity gains, and create a more positive environment for customers.

Simply put, loyal employees lead to loyal customers.

Great service leaders recognize that improving employee retention involves providing opportunities for growth and advancement. This approach keeps talented employees closer to the customer for longer periods, which directly impacts customer satisfaction and loyalty.

Take Whole Foods Market, for example. They have crafted their entire system — from their rigorous selection process to compensation methods — to encourage front-line employees to stay and thrive. Teams at Whole Foods are responsible for setting key metrics, making decisions on how to meet these targets, and even choosing what food items to buy locally. They’re rewarded with bonuses based on team performance, which often includes finding creative ways to boost sales to balance out labor costs. After three years on the job, employees receive stock options, which further incentivizes them to stay.

Additionally, Whole Foods allows employees to vote every three years on various aspects of the benefits package, from community service pay to health insurance provisions. All these factors contribute to Whole Foods’ remarkably low turnover rate of less than 10 percent for full-time employees after the probationary period — far below the industry average.

The results speak for themselves: Whole Foods is regularly rated as one of the best places to work, known for excellent customer service, and boasts some of the highest profits per square foot in the grocery retail industry.

This success is a testament to the power of employee loyalty in driving exceptional service. Great service leadership isn’t just about managing day-to-day operations — it’s about creating an environment where employees feel valued, empowered, and committed. By focusing on employee loyalty, service leaders can build stronger customer relationships and achieve sustainable success.

Employees First For All Leaders

You may not have the power in your organization to completely flip the hierarchy. But there’s still an important lesson for leaders at all levels: Flip the accountability. This can look like bringing in more feedback from front-line employees or just seeing the structure of your team differently. You work for your team. Don’t squeeze your team; foster them to do well.

In addition, give your employees real stakes and invest in them. Prioritize training and growth opportunities for your employees so they know you’re committed to not just their output, but their career. Parties, gift certificates, awards, summer Fridays, bonuses — all of these are great. Do those things. But those are more employee appreciation, not real development. Development looks like sending your rising stars to conferences, workshops, night school even, if you have the budget. Things you think will help them grow as employees, spark innovation, and create future leaders.

Conclusion

If I could put a message on a billboard in front of every Fortune 500 company, it would be this:

People don’t work for you.

Smart leaders know that employees work with them, and ultimately, leaders work for their people. Embracing the “employees first, customers second” philosophy means prioritizing the well-being and growth of employees, enabling them to deliver outstanding service. Happy, engaged employees create satisfied customers. When leaders invest in their teams’ success and happiness, they cultivate a culture where customers feel valued, leading to long-term loyalty and a thriving business.

HALLOWEEN BONUS: Save 30% on the eBook, hardcover or softcover of Braden Kelley’s latest book Charting Change (now in its second edition) — FREE SHIPPING WORLDWIDE — using code HAL30 until midnight October 31, 2025

Image credit: David Burkus

Subscribe to Human-Centered Change & Innovation WeeklySign up here to get Human-Centered Change & Innovation Weekly delivered to your inbox every week.front

Holistic Metrics for Customer Experience Innovation

Leave a reply

Beyond NPS

Holistic Metrics for Customer Experience Innovation

GUEST POST from Art Inteligencia

In the world of customer experience (CX), the Net Promoter Score (NPS) has become the gold standard. With its simple, elegant question — “How likely are you to recommend us to a friend or colleague?” — it has given leaders a seemingly clear and powerful metric to track customer loyalty. And while NPS has served its purpose, it has, in my opinion, become a crutch. As a human-centered change and innovation thought leader, I am here to argue that chasing a single score is a dangerous oversimplification. It tells you what is happening, but it provides almost no insight into why or how to fix it. The future of customer experience innovation belongs to organizations that move beyond a single number and embrace a holistic, multi-dimensional metric framework that captures the full, rich tapestry of the customer journey.

The problem with a metric like NPS is that it is a lagging indicator. It measures the outcome of an experience, but it doesn’t diagnose the cause. It’s like a doctor taking your temperature and knowing you have a fever, but having no idea if the cause is a minor cold or a serious infection. This singular focus can lead to a host of negative consequences: a lack of actionable insight, a disconnection from real customer behavior, and a dangerous internal obsession with “gaming the number” at the expense of genuine customer value. To truly innovate the customer experience, we must stop chasing a score and start understanding the human story behind it. We need to measure not just what customers say, but what they do and how they feel.

Building a Holistic CX Metric Framework: The Three Dimensions

A more effective approach to measuring customer experience involves a framework that looks at three distinct, yet interconnected, dimensions. These are your essential innovation levers:

  • 1. Behavioral Metrics (The “What”): These are the objective data points that show what your customers are actually doing. Metrics like repeat purchase rate, average session time, feature adoption, time to resolution for a support ticket, or product usage frequency provide hard, undeniable facts about customer engagement. These tell you if your product or service is truly creating value.
  • 2. Perceptual Metrics (The “How They Think”): This is where traditional scores can be useful, but in a more nuanced way. Metrics like Customer Effort Score (CES) — “How much effort did you have to put in to get your issue resolved?” — or Customer Satisfaction (CSAT) on a specific interaction are incredibly powerful. They tell you if the experience was easy, simple, and satisfying.
  • 3. Emotional Metrics (The “How They Feel”): This is the most critical and often overlooked dimension. It goes beyond a simple number to capture the emotional state of the customer. Use sentiment analysis on open-ended survey responses, call center transcripts, or social media comments. Qualitative feedback, such as an interview where a customer shares a story of a “wow” moment or a frustrating interaction, provides the color and context that no score ever could.

In the pursuit of holistic experience management, many of my clients are turning to strategic partners to help them build the necessary infrastructure. A great example of this is the work being done by companies like HCLTech, which helps clients implement Experience Management Offices (XMOs). These are not just new departments; they are a centralized command center for an organization’s entire experience ecosystem. By creating a dedicated XMO, companies can move beyond siloed efforts and begin to measure and manage experiences for their customers, partners, and employees as a unified whole. This includes the deployment of Experience Level Measures (XLMs), a set of sophisticated metrics that go far beyond a simple NPS score. XLMs capture the full journey, measuring everything from emotional sentiment and perceived effort to behavioral data and digital engagement. It’s a fundamental shift from a reactive, score-based approach to a proactive, human-centered one, ensuring that every touchpoint is optimized for a truly superior experience.

“The best metric is not a score; it’s a story. And a holistic framework gives you the chapters, the characters, and the plot points you need to innovate.”

Case Study 1: Zappos and the Obsession with “Wow”

The Challenge:

In the early 2000s, Zappos faced the monumental challenge of building a viable e-commerce business for shoes, a category that many believed would never succeed online due to the need for a physical try-on. The challenge was not just to sell shoes but to create a customer experience so exceptional that it would overcome the inherent friction of online retail and build a brand on trust and loyalty.

The Holistic Metrics Response:

Zappos’ innovation was not just in their business model, but in their metric framework. While they tracked revenue, they were obsessed with delivering “wow” moments. They didn’t just measure Customer Satisfaction; they actively encouraged employees to spend a minimum of an hour on a single customer service call to build a deep, human connection. They measured the number of free shipping upgrades to delight customers. The company was willing to spend money on a customer call or shipping because they understood the immense, long-term value of an emotional connection. Their core metric wasn’t NPS; it was the number of times they could surprise and delight a customer. Their behavioral metric was the high rate of repeat purchases, which they knew was a direct result of the positive emotions they fostered.

The Result:

Zappos became famous for its customer service. The emotional and behavioral metrics they prioritized directly led to high customer lifetime value and an army of loyal brand advocates. This focus on the holistic experience was their primary innovation, and it created a level of brand love that was almost impossible for competitors to replicate. The lesson: by measuring the moments that matter, you can build a more resilient and beloved business.

Case Study 2: HubSpot’s Proactive Customer Health Score

The Challenge:

In the world of B2B SaaS, customer churn is a constant threat. Historically, companies would rely on a lagging indicator — cancellation — to know when a customer was at risk. The challenge for HubSpot, a leader in marketing and sales software, was to move from a reactive posture to a proactive one. They wanted to know a customer was unhappy or disengaged long before they decided to leave.

The Holistic Metrics Response:

HubSpot developed a “Customer Health Score” as their primary innovation metric. This wasn’t a simple survey result; it was a holistic metric composed of three key dimensions:

  1. Behavioral: How often were they logging in? Were they adopting and using the key features of the software? Was their team size expanding or contracting?
  2. Perceptual: What was their satisfaction with the support team?
  3. Emotional: What was the sentiment from a recent check-in call with their account manager?

By combining these dimensions, HubSpot could see a comprehensive view of a customer’s health. For example, a customer who was logging in less frequently and had a recent low satisfaction score would be flagged as at-risk, even if they hadn’t expressed a desire to leave. This gave the team a chance to intervene and innovate the experience — by offering more training, providing personalized support, or addressing a specific pain point — before it was too late.

The Result:

HubSpot’s proactive, holistic approach to customer health significantly reduced churn and increased customer lifetime value. By moving beyond a single metric like NPS and instead focusing on the full story of customer behavior, perception, and emotion, they were able to build a more resilient customer base and a product that continuously evolved to meet customer needs. This case study proves that a holistic metric framework is not just a tool for measurement but a powerful engine for continuous innovation.

Conclusion: The Future of Experience is Human

A single score, no matter how elegant, is an oversimplification of the complex human experience. It is a tool for the passive manager, not the human-centered innovator. The most successful organizations of the future will be those that have the courage to move beyond the comfort of a single number and embrace the messy, beautiful complexity of their customers’ lives. By building a holistic metric framework that measures what people do, how they think, and how they feel, we can move from simply managing customer satisfaction to truly innovating the human experience.

The time has come to stop chasing a number and start listening to the human story. The next great innovation is not hiding in a spreadsheet; it’s waiting for you to find it in the heart of your customer’s journey.

Extra Extra: Futurology is not fortune telling. Futurists use a scientific approach to create their deliverables, but a methodology and tools like those in FutureHacking™ can empower anyone to engage in futurology themselves.

Image credit: Unsplash

Subscribe to Human-Centered Change & Innovation WeeklySign up here to get Human-Centered Change & Innovation Weekly delivered to your inbox every week.