How E-commerce Must Proactively Manage Experiences Created Without Their Consent
LAST UPDATED: November 7, 2025 at 4:31 PM
GUEST POST from Art Inteligencia
A fundamental shift is underway in the world of e-commerce, moving control of the customer journey out of the hands of the brand and into the hands of the AI Agent. The recent lawsuit by Amazon against Perplexity regarding unauthorized access to user accounts by its agentic browser is not an isolated legal skirmish; it is a red flag moment for every company that sells online. The core challenge is this: AI agents are building and controlling the shopping experience — the selection, the price comparison, the checkout path — often without the e-commerce site’s knowledge or consent.
This is the AI Agent Paradox: The most powerful tool for customer convenience (the agent) simultaneously poses the greatest threat to brand control, data integrity, and monetization models. The era of passively optimizing a webpage is over. The future belongs to brands that actively manage their relationship with the autonomous, agentic layer that sits between them and their human customers.
The Three Existential Threats of the Autonomous Agent
Unmanaged AI agents, operating as digital squatters on your site, create immediate systemic problems for e-commerce sites:
- Data Integrity and Scraping Overload: Agents typically use resource-intensive web scraping techniques that overload servers and pollute internal analytics. The shopping experience they create is invisible to the brand’s A/B testing and personalization engines.
- Brand Bypass and Commoditization: Agents prioritize utility over loyalty. If a customer asks for “best price on noise-cancelling headphones,” the agent may bypass your brand story, unique value propositions, and even your preferred checkout flow, reducing your products to mere SKU and price points. This is the Brand Bypass threat.
- Security and Liability: Unauthorized access, especially to user accounts (as demonstrated by the Amazon-Perplexity case), creates massive security vulnerabilities and legal liability for the e-commerce platform, which is ultimately responsible for protecting user data.
The How-To: Moving from Resistance to Proactive Partnership
Instead of relying solely on defensive legal action (which is slow and expensive), e-commerce brands must embrace a proactive, human-centered API strategy. The goal is to provide a superior, authorized experience for the AI agents, turning them from adversaries into accelerated sales channels — and honoring the trust the human customer places in their proxy.
Step 1: Build the Agent-Optimized API Layer
Treat the AI agent as a legitimate, high-volume customer with unique needs (structured data, speed). Design a specific, clean Agent API separate from your public-facing web UI. This API should allow agents to retrieve product information, pricing, inventory status, and execute checkout with minimal friction and maximum data hygiene. This immediately prevents the resource-intensive web scraping that plagues servers.
Step 2: Define and Enforce the Rules of Engagement
Your Terms of Service (TOS) must clearly articulate the acceptable use of your data by autonomous agents. Furthermore, the Agent API must enforce these rules programmatically. You can reward compliant agents (faster access, richer data) and throttle or block non-compliant agents (those attempting unauthorized access or violating rate limits). This is where you insert your brand’s non-negotiables, such as attribution requirements or user privacy protocols, thereby regaining control.
Step 3: Offer Value-Added Agent Services and Data
This is the shift from defense to offense. Give agents a reason to partner with you and prefer your site. Offer exclusive agent-only endpoints that provide aggregated, structured data your competitors don’t, such as sustainable sourcing information, local inventory availability, or complex configurator data. This creates a competitive advantage where the agent actually prefers to send traffic to your optimized channel because it provides a superior outcome for the human user.
Case Study 1: The Furniture Retailer and the AI Interior Designer
Challenge: Complex, Multivariable E-commerce Decisions
A high-end furniture and décor retailer struggled with low conversion rates because buying furniture requires complex decisions (size, material, delivery time). Customers were leaving the site to use third-party AI interior design tools.
Proactive Partnership:
The retailer created a “Design Agent API.” This API didn’t just provide price and SKU; it offered rich, structured data on 3D model compatibility, real-time customization options, and material sustainability scores. They partnered with a leading AI interior design platform, providing the agent direct, authorized access to this structured data. The AI agent, in turn, could generate highly accurate virtual room mock-ups using the retailer’s products. This integration streamlined the complex path to purchase, turning the agent from a competitor into the retailer’s most effective pre-visualization sales tool.
Case Study 2: The Specialty Grocer and the AI Recipe Planner
Challenge: Fragmented Customer Journey from Inspiration to Purchase
An online specialty grocer, focused on rare and organic ingredients, saw their customers using third-party AI recipe planners and shopping list creators, which often failed to locate the grocer’s unique SKUs or sent traffic to competitors.
Proactive Partnership:
The grocer developed a “Recipe Fulfillment Endpoint.” They partnered with two popular AI recipe apps. When a user generated a recipe, the AI agent, using the grocer’s endpoint, could instantly check ingredient availability, price, and even offer substitute suggestions from the grocer’s unique inventory. The agent generated a “One-Click, Fully-Customized Cart” for the grocer. The grocer ensured the agent received a small attribution fee (a form of commission), turning the agent into a reliable, high-converting affiliate sales channel. This formalized partnership eliminated the friction between inspiration and purchase, driving massive, high-margin sales.
The Human-Centered Imperative
Ultimately, this is a human-centered change challenge. The human customer trusts their AI agent to act on their behalf. By providing a clean, transparent, and optimized path for the agent, the e-commerce brand is honoring that trust. The focus shifts from control over the interface to control over the data and the rules of interaction. This strategy not only improves server performance and data integrity but also secures the brand’s place in the customer’s preferred, agent-mediated future.
“The AI agent is your customer’s proxy. If you treat the proxy poorly, you treat the customer poorly. The future of e-commerce is not about fighting the agents; it’s about collaborating with them to deliver superior value.” — Braden Kelley
The time to move beyond the reactive defense and into proactive partnership is now. The e-commerce leaders of tomorrow will be the ones who design the best infrastructure for the machines that shop for humans. Your essential first step: Form a dedicated internal team to prototype your Agent API, defining the minimum viable, structured data you can share to incentivize collaboration over scraping.
Image credit: Google Gemini
Sign up here to get Human-Centered Change & Innovation Weekly delivered to your inbox every week.